Career advice

Hints & tips on interviews, CV’s and personal branding

Social Media

LinkedIN, Twitter, Facebook & UK Marketing Network

Recruitment Views

Recruitment thoughts, observation & commentary

Marketing News

All the latest news from from the marketing world

Home » Industry Commentry, Job boards, Recruitment Views

Why are recruiters trying to kill job boards?

Submitted by Simon Lewis on March 25, 2010 – 8:22 am3 Comments
Number of View: 326

online_job_search Advertising your job properly online can be a tough nut to crack.  How much information should you expose and what makes compelling copy?

 

A job description isn’t a sales tool and never will be so what does jiggle the juices of a marketing jobseeker?

 

A job description isn’t …,
by Alasdair Murray Mar 24, 2010

For reasons best known to themselves, many recruiters bemoan the absence of a decent job description and person spec from a client. I agree it’s frustrating when what you get is a series of seemingly unrelated one liners in terms of a job description and just the basic facts about the skills and experience you need in order to do the role, but, the emphasis should be on you, the recruiter to eke out the information from your client that will sell the job, not to cut and paste the bare bones of a dull and uninspiring JD and person spec onto a job board entry template.

In short – the job description is not a sales tool, it’s merely a checklist of duties.

Inspired advertising

I know that some of them can be pretty dire (but often memorable), but imagine if every commercial break on television was filled with hideously dull advertising. For instance, instead of seeing Papa and Nicole prancing around the French countryside, you were faced with Sid, a mechanic in scruffy overalls, droning on about the technical specification of the latest Renault. Indeed, imagine that no decent TV ads had ever been made. No ‘vorsprung durch technik’. No meerkats, no Smash robots, no Boddingtons top bombing – just dull offering after dull offering after dull offering, every day and every night.

No regard for the vacancy

Now think about all too-typical job board content. A lot of it is recruitment’s equivalent to listening to Sid and his monotonous tones. It seems that just as most product advertisers go to great lengths and expense to bring allure and memorability to their commercial offerings, so many recruiters pay little or no regard to the need to actually sell the vacancy they are trying to fill.

Who cares about the ad anyway?

There is, of course, an argument that says what does it matter what you post? After all, people don’t read the ads anyway. Apparently they just scan them for job title, salary and location and then hit the ‘apply’ button. But what kind of candidate doesn’t actually read about the job they are applying for? The desperate? The ones with no eye for detail? The ones devoid of decent listening skills? Certainly not the good quality ones I would wager. But then so many recruiters make it difficult to want to read their job advertisements in the first place because they are just so deathly dull and boring. Particularly the ones that seem to think that a job description IS a sales tool.

Managing the response

I firmly believe that when it comes to advertising – any advertising – you get out what you put in. If recruiters let their people blindly cut and paste job descriptions and fire them scatter gun style then yes, they will get a response, but it will invariably be of extremely poor quality – and that will apply whether you put it on a job board or a link to it on a social media site.

Allure, intrigue, excitement…

…opportunity, challenge and reward, the feeling that the ad is talking to the job seeker, personally – all are essential ingredients to anyone who wants to get a good response from their recruitment advertising. Unless, of course, you’d rather see recruitment’s answer to Sid reading from his manual littering the job boards and social media sites? But if you would, I wouldn’t hold your breath for a decent response.

Some say the job board is dying. I don’t believe it is, despite many recruiters doing their level best to kill them off by posting up really bad job ads. So, here it is, one last time – a job description is not a sales tool (so don’t cut and paste them anymore, please).

 

Alasdair Murray is a freelance copywriter and interim recruitment advertising professional

 

Edited by Simon Lewis | Editor | Only Marketing Jobs

Related posts:

  1. What is the future for job boards and how can recruiters evolve?
  2. Job boards versus recruitment agencies: the gathering storm
  3. How jobseeker behaviour affects job boards
  4. How do recruiters find the best candidates?
  5. Recruiters preparing for 2010 lift-off
  6. Why aren’t recruiters socially accepting?
  7. Only recruiters with a social media strategy will survive
  8. Why are recruiters ignoring me?
  9. Recruiters: treat your candidates like a good neighbour, or die
  10. How to write an effective job brief for online recruitment advertising

3 Comments »

  • Alasdair,

    Totally agree with your rhetoric here – “job description is not a sales tool”

    I preach it to every client I work for, and they seem genuinly surprised when you tell them this!

    Maybe you should set up a series of free workshops to deliver your message?

    Andy

  • Stephen says:

    All too true, its the same when you are canvassing companies. If each call is different and specific to that organisation, you will have more success.

    Very few consultants spend time on the phone getting the real details of the vacancies, again the more detail the better the ad, the more detail the easier to sell to candidates that applied, the more detail the candidate is better prepared and guess what! The better chance you have in placing someone with the client too.

  • PC says:

    I once went to see a client, and as he had no job description, I wrote one based on our conversation, to be used by other consultants. I sent it to him for approval and he was very pleased. Imagine my surprise when 2 days later when I saw my job description word for word on another recruiters ad!! Needless to say I wasn’t best pleased!

    Too many ads nowadays are just cut and pasted job descriptions, and it doesn’t engage with the candidate, and is not providing clients with value for money or a proper service. What it also does, is that it often gives clues on who the client is, which can often mean the recruiter being bypassed, many times I see a clients name in an ad as they have copied and pasted the job description without checking it.

Leave a comment!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.

Get Adobe Flash playerPlugin by wpburn.com wordpress themes